The Periodic Table of Videos: a great idea ruined by poor execution

| 0 Comments

The University of Nottingham’s Periodic Table of Videos is a genius idea - one that I wish I had come up with myself. I’d really like to recommend the site to teachers because short videos of those elements you can’t show in class would be incredibly useful. Unfortunately, due to the varying quality of the videos, the site fails to live up to its potential. The idea of inter-cutting footage of demonstrations with a scientist talking about the element just doesn’t work in a lot of the videos; I would have preferred the two aspects to be separated. I have some other problems with the videos and the website, but I’m reluctant to write about them here because I like the idea so much that I just feel mean ripping it apart. I know a couple of chemists who virtually froth at the mouth with anger when talking about this site - I totally understand their frustration with it.

Leave a comment

Blog posts

BBC iScience films for GCSE Science
A few years ago, I helped make a bunch of films intended for use in GCSE Science lessons. I was…
Physics Demonstration Videos
Thanks to the generosity and support of The National STEM Centre and the Institute of Physics, Jonathan Sanderson and I,…
Science vs Magic - a work in progress
It’s a few days since I came back from the Cheltenham Science Festival and I’m still buzzing. My live science…
King of the Universe
This is a piece I wrote for The Times Science Blog back in March 2010. The Times no longer allow…
The Danger of Science Denial
I’ve recently been marking GCSE “case studies” - coursework where students get to “research a science related question” e.g., Should…